Case LawAfrican Union / Regional Courts
92/93 International PEN (in respect of Kemal al Jazouli) v Sudan
10 January 1970
Headnotes
Type: Decision | Keywords: Right to Fair Trial, Personal Liberty, Exhaustion of Local Remedies, Admissibility | Outcome: Ruled Inadmissible | State: Sudan
Judgment
92/93 International PEN (in respect of Kemal al-Jazouli)
/ Sudan
The Facts
1. The communication concerns one Kemal Al Jazouli, who was held incommunicado without charge from
March to June 1992. During this period he had no opportunity to challenge his detention in a court of law.
Complaint
2. The complaint alleges violation of Articles 6 and 7 of the African Charter.
Decision
3. The Commission is of the opinion that none of the information given whether taken individually or
together can constitute exhaustion of local remedies. The victim was tried in June 1992 and the complaint
was lodged with the Commission in March 1993. He had ample freedom to exhaust local remedies before
he approached the Commission. The fact that the Government has in general terms denied the existence
of incommunicado detentions in Sudan does not amount to saying that the case has been tried in
Sudanese courts.
For these reasons, the Commission
Declares the communication inadmissible for non-exhaustion of local remedies.
1
Similar Cases
Communication 268/03 - Ilesanmi v. Nigeria
63% similar
232/99 John D. Ouko v Kenya
58% similar