Hadima Yusuf vs Fusto Kyesile (PC Civil Appeal No. 56 of 1990) [1991] TZHC 2418 (3 September 1991)

,.. ,· / ----··· .. -· ... --· \tz·r~·,-e_s~~ IH rw;, .1...-...;J.J '.}IGTI. co·::::.·;::: OF TtJTZ.:"JTIL'. . i.T 11W/JTZA ,."il'?::JLLi.:.C~ J71J1IS~)IC'1 1 IOlT (PC) CIVIL· i.Pr->n"·-~ ;O. 56 OF 1990 (Froo tho : 1 .cci.ion oi J.;;·o .uint?::ic·t Cour·i; of .3ulco'bc:. ·.-:irs:;:,.,j_o· r/G ]ukoba . ' in Civil ippco.1 I:o.65 0f 19e7 - :Sc1orc J., Ko H Ht1.ft1.:.,,e;o,'l:::::q., DioJli:ri'ct }I.:v.;i1tlirc.to and 0ri2,ind.. Urbz:i.n Prir.t0I'Y Court Civil 0<'A::c ,;.37 of 1986) '. .. . .. l!fi.DilTl YCSUF. ~ d e O O e O o. • 0 O 3 • O • .,••it e ~ •• 0. & '..? •• ,, e .. 0 • 4'. I• 0 • d •• iP.CLL:"JIT Vl'ill.SUS ]'""GSTQ ICIJ:SD:I;. • do • • o o o 13 a • a -t • o ,. -. • • ., a o o o • • o •I• t • • • e • • • •••·••fl 0 . eRT!SFOlTTJ:rT J U D G II E H T mnr.rmt:. 1 J • : . ', Tl~q nppc'iE1.11t ~rnd ·;;J:o :,l:·.:L:;tiff in t!:-,o FriDt.l'j" 'Jnu.:::--',, :"'.O ouocl t!:.o rcopor.clont :tor rocovm.jr of 2, pL100 of .= oLc'2111a c'.·:.c ol·,:i.,1c::. ;,.o ·1c.ti:or 11;:>cl "''1Cr0""1....,,, O'' r+ .,,,, 1,--,. ('''"" .•.•;,, ❖ 0n 10/10/86 .... , 0 ,,;-,, ... ,, ~""'" poo"'lO VJ. ,:n.,,,.' •• ,........... .Lo. V '.,,,1-.J ..;_ -"~ kJ., d ... -.,u ,,, ·, ' •·• :_.:,:.,.i. .,Jl_,,......i ,i.l i ,, h,-.r n',:·1'1-.-., cul.,i•v,·'·1·",,• 1 r··"l!'T, "'•o m, .... +1·"'·1··• 1 ·'·' 1 0"' ,•. ,,-· ( .. • . . ;·•1,--,• 1 +'--c·•y .l.e ..... v u . . ,,).J~ l, ..... I.I --uJ . ---y ..... ·-'•··:. "1.'-'J.J"" :-,0·4 \J .... ,,. - - v. •-.,lrJ J,,, ,-l.. ---- ,J. 9. ',n r 1) tY'n 1· 1"' nt-·10t(•·': 1:r,t •!•!·-c· ~ .. ,.,,,,.,o·,r~ 0'"';~ to ,.,.. ... ;:• 1· 11 -'l·', C ···'· .. .-,';" -'-" C'>'pl-·., .--.-1 -~~··"'"'- ,.. ...., .a.i..i •"- .......... "u t• .. - _ ........ .;. ,.,.,. .. _ .i.4v f-...,..L ... - ,... , ....... "'-· <..,• ~J--V .. J-\ c.~J.i .. v ...... to tho aut>or;ii.-y o.ncl ·i;. 1 :.on r;:· .. .::: :cilo:t ·ii::io :::P.i-t. Jlry'.;·-. r-;i '.or; . ,lL.l niJmcoaco, -~~ , "-.11-,,,t ...,,,11 1 ·"'. ( r.) ~ .. .:: -:• 1 ·..., r•,n ..... ,, ... 1,t ..., ·11·· ;: -:-·- , (· ... ) TI·· - w .. C o;~)...e .. , -• '"-• cc. J. lVC ) .. ,,_ ...... ·" ,,.,po~-1-- ~ • ..,, , '"·· ~ ... re.a -:, • Q trin.l cotu't vici-'liocl t:.·.o -'inpn·:,o:'. ci-co • • I. P' ;.:.H ~ J..l:. ~ .; . .".C -;.' '.0 o.: .. ·:rt f .:- tu:::. t:.:.o nll..,,,,t ,, 1 p· ... ovo'' '·or O•"C'•, .... ,,r, ............ po11'0!'1 ... ' 1 "' 1 1··, , .. ,,,.. ... Q'1"J"'''"•r" J.1.,0 -.1pf,v '-.a..:. .' ... O.C... 4 u. •·- ' .,, , ,11J.i' ti: .) L Vt.I .. , ,1. ... t, ..• ·..,.,.'. .L- -• i:...>J V - 1.JI-' ... .... U;... boiu1ck,ry mc.l oocupicd ·l:.o i:-,p~)cll2 .• :rli'o si:lc, ju~lcpon•;; w:'JJ :.1r· 0 not"J1c:.d in ho:x.- f<1.v01.i.r, Jul-le rospon'~~c1'lt ~)~~c:c-J.cd. -'co -'c!c Dio-t:i:·io., Cocc•·i; w: .. ich nullifi0,1. -';;10 proccoi'..inc;o n.nd. orderer'. <'- ·'.<:; 1ovo trb.l. 1 rllo zprcllcn;; :.,roue].:'li -'i;::.i:.:: n.pponl op,ooing t:.-:c orclor for ;:,, rotric..l on c,;rot'J.1:-l ti'.;;; -:·.0::::-0 H".rJ 110 i3"oocl rev.con for tI'.c orc1or. In pc:ru.oinc- the juc'!.o'.10:rt of the Diotrict Cour·~ I f onr.cl the roa.cono fo~ ordorilv; c retrial were -two :i:rJlcl, firs·I; t?1.<",t t>o etri. t c:,.c::.i:iba b.:,lo11Gocl to t1:o r,,ppclla11t/plo.ir:.'Giff I a c',l'.n.i; Zoi.1c'bio. oo tho.t oJ.:c ( :~;:>pclLmt) hD.d no locuo cte .. ndi • But Zone hi::. ( PW2) .-:;::,,,vc cvi :lone c .:1.ac:. c;;dcl r.f· o :·.acl ill □ truc"vo'.: -~1:o appoll2.i1t to o · ·1,:'..i..'!fY; t:10 suit on · .er :·,ob;i,lf ~1002.u.sc 0::1.0 ~ ...... ,., in ..,. ·noor hc"'ll"-h I fi-rl -~0 ❖ ··1· ~- .,,...,.....,,./' 3.' n t, .. ,....,. . .. ,. ,, ·1 .... •-7 (Vi "' ., ) n11.-1ti..J LI, ,..., ~ · .. ,. U • -.:..i.... ;..4\ v .• "".!tG Yt.&.' ... 1"--"t..> • "-c....,ll'' b .. ·v ;,.,v· ••• 'J •+-..• pQroi-to ::i.. rola.tivo to roprcccut o.nottor in Prin,r-J C•:ir.:.:-·o ui t>.( 1 .. -:.t f'lTJT lOG'2l cooplicn;tion □• Tho ooconc1. rcm:ion wt.:y t'..10 ro·crid wr· .. ~ cri0:rod W<'JJ t l•,·,t t'''•"' ''TJ1'"•llnnt f;-,ilo- -~-"\ J··J1·11 one ~ ....... o,··t ~:,hr:1r,,,l,•,,: .... (p1;.r3) ~,· t·-,. .... c,.,, .:...- t.¥,1.,-,,; -..:.t..l .,._ \ •• " \ ..J ♦ .L.,l, t,j ........ ...,c.-.. ... •.•. .i;__, ., ., .. ) ......... r ,..,opon-· 1 --.·,t''"' co -"-,fc·1,-,,,.,t 1T11,.;r, ,.._d nr-t· :1, -J -·'o 1 ri·'·' .·.,. c,··r·t J.,.,., v .• vJ.- 1..) - ... ;......, ,l. •• .,M-.1. ♦ J..:.o-:..J ......... • ..... .....!. •0, vl ~ - ~ - \r. • 1,., .. ,..: .1' '·'.. , • Vh.J . w,s to :',.ocLlo tho norii;c C::: -;; .1.:. t.1,ppoo..l bofo:ro it. I q::i·;;o r-.,::;:rvc wi ·i;h tho appollc:u:.t -;:at t:'.o or-lor of o, rotrio.l wno tmo~.J.lc :. :~ xc t>.o:.:'o ,: ··,a no f,'.:..tol irrceulari t;,; in the procc,J::'..i.1go to avoid-the- tri0l~ ···I tLor-;:;foi-c·· oot n.oi,J.o .. -.\o orclor for c, ro·(n.:'itl. !iow tto :.1cd ta of -:·.o c,...,so. Tho • ..... /2. I :l

;{ :r, ....,.,- ... 2 - c.ppollo.r.t ha.cl c~-.,llccl one "Erncot l!::lyanuk.,'lJ:1a. (PW3) w~-o 2.,.t'lJ:1 sol'.'. :.., s>.c.,;.:ba to t ''O r·•'"'nOll-'"lt ..,,1,l W~'.l..C'' ·),,,,1 . .., COM1""IO'l bo·1n•".,,.,.,r -11· •!·"· ·'·'·o- ...,,,·.-,11.-,,-,tts --- .,;i,:> l ..... ..., ,4 -.II. ',.,.. .. ·- ,1...·. • •.• (..,__ t, 1 • H ..... .l i I,. "'- --C :-'-rJ t \I... u. . <.. "-'- ·'· ...,, - ,W..j. fl llo showd -the bouncl::ry o .. nc.l -•-,.o .c-);u-t bclicv·.::cl >.is cvi-·.0:.,.oc. Upon nu.ch J. •nfor·1--.,:ti,..,,,, •'Gl·o court c1ro~"" s'<·,·••,-I, nl,:, 1 ·1 ,.,,vl ....,,1.,- 0 .,:, .. rr;r,,,,-,•o ·nt 1 ""L cro,..·,-,' -1.....,.. ,.:.,-....., 7·: : •- '·ll ., ••-"-" ""'4.:..- i-' C. (..,....,.. .J..-'-- ,; .. '. .. l• .•• ·..; ..,,J.:,1-.,!.!. VI- J..,'-,, !. .;J:..>U~:. -'·he boi 1 •1d:1'1"'11' :1 1 ·1cl O'lC ... ..,..,,.., .. ,.,c'. ri1 1 .,,_ "I ... n.:..--11-,·t•s. s'·-,-l,..., ;;i,,;'"' w--n ,., mioc,-1·3.' 0' 1 V- -....:. : .... J s-,-,. .,. J,, ....,.,~~ .. .::,iv :, • - L, ••• i..; t,;,.1., .i-" .... J.. ........... -.; 11...:-. ...:......LO :.. {,..:,, "1.'"'"" ~ V .;.. of c:rcd.ihili ty, tl10 trio.l COl'.I"t i:::. cJ.weys 'i;:::.o :iu;;;t jt'.: 1 0 0 ·::-:•Jr it, to.orc is no .rcnsn. to fc1t.1lt Hs (led.a.ion .. _ I allow Jlib.o appc:a',l, oct 0,oi ·.o tl:c rlccioion of Jli;).O District Court r.i..1,1' rcs·oro· t}::..;!.t ::f Ur'!..11:J l.":rir:.r.!.1'.'"'J Court with costs. I i I I .It~~ tfj. · h '" JI ""''- . . :\Ii.. -v-~ .;,ti~\ ~1 1, ~ .1:J ~l1 ..;I/ ' CTI:Li'!IFr -:. (SGD) • F. ~. ·· !IIOliY:l:U.A JUDGE. TD'.i'.!r OOS IS l-. TRDI: COP'l OF T:IE ORIGLT ~~ DISTi:Uci 'runGIS·.u:Lt.ll w.~ir( hi ' ... ') ., J :} 'f . ... . \ .