Petro Urio vs Zakayo (PC Civil Appeal No. 3 of 1988) [1991] TZHC 2745 (15 August 1991)

(FC) CrJIL A:fI'~-J, :tTOo 3 OF 0 F1983 01I}I1Z'~L CI 1 t:u., ;·::.>·1,',.L no. 51/8€iliCSj:r. DISTRICT COURT AT nos:..:r J U D G 1"i p lf T. T;:.:Lo fo n socond. n:c,;;)o::\l fror:1 tho Eos'..li Dist:eict Oou:d Civil li.p::i;;c2,l l:c). 51 of 1986 ori,3'in2-ll;y- r:1-dkc'1. I'ric_:,.ry C01xd Civil Gas,) No. 34 of 1S:C5. In the snia_ ;):ri;x·.ry court t!w :Jlainti:ff ; .. borinoco Zc1lmyo, tho ,;::,:or,cnt :c"os;onclcnt suod. f 0:;:, 2 ccttlo, a h.oif'or and. n hull ros]_::oct:'.voly frbu1 t>, cl,.::2ond.cnt retro :i'Tdoonc,:sic, the present c1:;::;,ollrmt.

i1~, ... --..1n•• ~ J:t i ._ . .,.,.,r••·,:l ,-.-•• i-..r, -'t•;.I C'I • •V ,/·-'···J.ntJ_f.L c_c,,,,,,Cc ,_., l, t,.,,..; t.LJ.c.,l ao SK1 std;iY.!{£ t)i.ct in 1965 t: .. , :..lc::::;.11cl2.nt l1irod his cmt l.'11dcr ChE':::.':s2• custorJo T>,.c cow co.lvcc.l only oi-::0O oo t>.c dofoml,mt oxc. 1 .'.."J:1-{;0d it ·to get a rcoro proctucti vo cowo Tho ncu 00'"T c,oli vcroc:t Cl, bull w:j_c.l tJ1i.) pl2,intiff a,J.lowod tb.o dofvnclctnt to lcco:;. ~ ;:.::.l)l1 t),c cow c2.lvod ['S.---,:'t.l'1 tllo dofon0_2.11t c'ccclincd tc- sUJ:rcndm: T:!.C ;:d;::·,ry cou:d fc:1..mcl t:,,,:t t10 1 1 12..i tiff hal :.;roved :1.is c2.s0 en t>::i ·::~~L',nco of ::._wo1x'.:bili.tios t10:rcby cntcr:L:y; ju:l::;,,mont for tho :, 1 J.i.Hiff. Diss2,tisfioiJ. 1dt'', t>-..:: decision of t):;,; tricJ cou.--rt tho In }.:.is mor:corandur,:i o:[_ 2,::;:.;:::;a,l the a:)pollnnt :;:0statod that b.c owos t:. 0 .0 clofoncl:::mt no cattle. Ho clairiod tl.1-.t t':i.0 ;ilaintiff 2.nd :.:d.s wi tnor:;sos (§-·,:;o cont,,2-dicto:ry c-;sj_rlcnco so t:·.c two sU')o'.'i:'cUn,:-to courts o:;:-:ronoo,::.s::.:_;=- :'!,:-:vc ju:";_2p.:;:.1t to t:·, plai tiff.,

I I 2 I I T:10 issue is whctllc:>: t~:.c defendant owes t;,.;J j)lc1i tiff tho two cJ.c,::.i.,cc~ :1Dc:,o. of cr1ttlo. T 1 ':.:, evidence of tho Jl2.i tiff wc.s ful]y corroborated by tho four w:l.tnor:,sos wl10 g2.,vo in his f£wour. Tho dofondantts n~•ro denial of t.o claiH hc:,s no mcri t in v:i.ow of the strong cvicknco adduced in su:;-:::o:-..~t of th:J plai tiff I s 0c.,so., O:rin 0 to the above rcnscns tho a:;::T,CJ.1 is dismissed with costs. It is so Ordered. At .. ~:rn,s>.c: t>:i.s 15/8/91. !.<ppollnnt g in person. ENM/ma. J-CTG:m. 15/8/ 1991. 15/8/ 1991,