Venance s/o Nkunuli vs Republic (HC Criminal Appeal No. 138 of 1989) [1991] TZHC 2658 (5 July 1991)

I' '. i;l :.. I f ! ! . . :tll··' ;: .. ..-,: -"'.' :Ill ;,:z · ItI:CiI;:. OOtl!l.T 01"' TAlIZ!JiL'l.. AT I,i;fANZA. APPELLATE JUJ1ISDICI1ION RIG'I COU2T Cllll,TllAL .tlPPEAL NO .. 138 OF 1989 ORIGD.'T.AL CRJMJN.AL CASE NO. 62 OF 1988 OF TD:E nsrR:i:CT OOVRT OF NGJlRA DISJ::Iar AT NG,".PJi. ffiTAJ:WE s/o NKUNULI 0 • • 0 • 0 t O • 0 C <i O ♦ C O O b ".I 'I e •• 0 0 0 0 0 0 o O O .0 0 e ••• e •• e AP!'>ELli.,oNT ( 0rigi1al .A:cuood) VItl.StJ!: Td DHll':!ID IUTI?UBL IC • o o • • • • o o ••• • -~ •• o •••• • ... • ••• • ., ••••••• ~ • •• o RES:POJ'JDilNT ( O:riginal :F:·. · · ,-cut n·) J uro ID'. i:sNT ' Two cot.o..- Steoling 1)Y Servant c/s 271 Gl1U 265· of t:.:-,0 Pe1cJ. Coe.le Ca;p. 16., KAT IT~ • . T!1e appellant Vcna11ce s/o Nkunuli, hnVL"'JG 1Jec:1 fe.cing tuo ounts, 2,lle3j_11G thut bet10c11 ;it.;.jc;/1987 2J1d 3rd/2/198C c:ncl between 8t11/5/1:-J57 1 t::.o said c,ppellc.nt r;tole Sl1s. 236,657.50 a,."ld 459,739. :fJ respectively, !1e Leme1:gecl convictecl t".S c:.1.:-.rc;edo Ile was sentenced to five ye:n:-s i;·.pr.t-- son:.1c.mt under t'.10 f1L1i:r1.u Sontencos r.ct 1972; u:·.iJ.o tile Sto,tu.tor-s· coape- nsr,tion O1d.0r followocl 0;1 heals.. T!1e 2.ppell.,1:.t ,{-;;(irievec';. has c.J?:)e2J.od, 0.£,:;;",2::.st convictions o ... 1d sontencoso ~0,vi11t3 SCI'l"{)tllOi.'..Sly G011G over the cviclo:100, I cc,nnot -c,1d11to,.i..11 non-alic;n;::e:,nt but c,erc0 ui t!.:: 11::,. Ynboncle, tl-.o J.oc,::;;.1od Str,te .,.-1,,ttornc;- o,?:.?0:wirig f'.or tho llc::;iu~:ilic, t:::d · ·,e: fic;1:cos 2.1Joli.t tho mov.nts, c.J.J.occcl.ly stolon 1·rcrc, so oix.oC: u:.9, 2..nd ovc.i·,.c,.p 3 :>ine;, tl::.ct :Lt '(i2.c iopossiblc, if not Vo:r.'j· c.ifficul t to :Lnc';.tify wl1icl: fic;ttrc j_o co:1:.1octod to wl1ic::. cotll1t, r-,nc: uJ.tinc.tcly w!lot:.:o:;:, sue;:;, fiGurC was stol0110 Fi:::nt c;.1d for0r.1ost, it 9bsc:rv0d · □ r;f 1Je L . tL,t t: .o t1-10 c.r.1ou_11ts ()f cash rlloj·ocUy stolon in t: .o tuo cou:.1ts, . wore alloc;odl;/ stolon during tho oo.r:c ]::,c:;:,iocl 8/<3/1937 - 3/2/1>GS, c.nc :ow ea.ch fi 6 Ul"C ltc:.s iclcntificd to constitEto t::'.0 first. or sccoml coti-1t, !·:..'.2.s not b0cn clwo:1sti'c.tcc:. by t!10 ovidcrce:, 11'.)r b3-· rolcv2 .. ;:lt clooi.1- . nonts. Iu1d if t.').o J?CJ:iot. is one, .::nd t):o noc.1:.a.,. oi stow.inc; is tl:.c sr.;:10 1 I cc,11::1ot sec tt.o ro::-.sor1 fo:;: prcfcrrinc; two counts. Jut narc dc.nc;c::>:i.oti.s, is t;.c risk potent it occr.1s, of duplicc.ting t) 1 .c sc.Do fisurosy t;:.o ::1:i.:"'.;1k · 1ct,icl.:. Cc.l1110t· Gtl...";XC,nt0o;'.- justice in t:c ce..soo Further 2.s :i:X-,. K.n'bond.c pointed out~. it cloos scoG c::.ncl c,::,pc2-t-, t~).o,t f:;;o:·, t:.o evidence of J:. W.1, 1h2,-'. &,oqu.o-i'To. c.50321 cl2.-tcd 10/9/15G7 fol" 3::.s. 104,737 /50 ur..s l'!lllX•,icl, but c:ross-oxDEinrtion oi' cvidcnoo sl:.ows tI.:..nt t . 11 t t 1" t' .,j.. t 1 t · t · J t 1 • t No. 5u 0 r.52 L,r:. 2.::,,0 r. 11 0 G. ,::.c C,Ol...'.u:-" il[', J. wa.s ,:,CC,l:::.s G . .';() '.i:OCCJ.]?. '"' of 17/12/1988. If ·Lfo ·1.J3 true? or tl..,cro j:J c~on:J_t r:.bout it, tho k::,11•0- t \

' ... .- ! -- . • .. ,· ·. ' ,-t', 7), .. ·ttc:·- . {m.' ,;;. . s1.P ..... "id. to c:;:•o-w11 :.i.t 2.11, th0z·e 1ri-,s io-prose.oution's ev:il.lonot/o :60• 1 ·: . . . :. . . ( ' . '. :'. ·:· . . ~ ' ' ;'' ;-..;.- sru.'10. :.Ee.in, while,· the r,-.-;::::JJ.ci1t- :Jr-;Lt1t2 i110g -the t. cvGn. 0°:si.1): lis-.4.,,;i, collected 'i:,3; him, was J.i!.'i:-- 1·,c.i,:. · rthq2 ·-c2:s-h ii~~s ,. no:t .. J:-oflctd · lt-i . • . . . . , • ., .. , ~ l . . , .. ••• - .- . ; ·,L, . ., • . • ,t.. • . -. . . )11. 1~)~ th2 2.1.J..cb.to1· 1 s 1•epm.-t, ·,!l.110,epo.. -c.1 e:r.:sm.in2..ion .. of.., the .. si.,.d :;~~::m:·t, aoes '·'.. '.. ''. ·•· • • · • ••• -. • , • 1, • t • . . ' ll not xov.e1:,,l such ·ftgu.t'e, no:.· ;)v::.clonce. to show. t!· 2 t t1:.c suJe ,;,rr.:s neve:e ::,-o;,- . (' • \ •·• • •• .... f I collected yitl1out. r13oei:,Jt, :::~ .. ,o:.:: the r:".Jove, 1 cm s, .. ti □ f:'.Gd 1Jeyond • · • • •' ' ,, 4 cl, t ~ , , ' ' .• • :;i:r-cOC!ventLi..:::·G'. thst tl:e· :,1:;;0FJCOt:t:io ·;.;;a1;c 'canri.ot . st2.11.d 9 ibc to'st of scl'ut:Ln;r, c.:p.c1 sup,ort corrv:; ot :Lons. I om .h :ful1 t'c;reor:1c;.:.t vitli the 102,1.•ned Sttod :~tto:i,~noi c:•.~2:,·:.0:,/:,.n::.· fcir the ·:,0:pu·'.Jli<3i tL.::t .,:1.t is-.-ti.nse,fc .to v.phoJ.d convictions, 2,s J:oof of tt.e ol:2..:t{5Cs 'be;rond :r?or•.soni blo doi~-:)t, 1:.es scarcely been r-.o:· .:i.ov0d. The ·,c.1):rec.l is h0:;:01J~· rJ.lowod, con- v:i, ct iol:'.IJ3 quashed ,-J'la·: ·sonton.oop sot a.side.·. 'I'he c::::,:0::-J 11:: ::it to ;;0 so.t :t;.:-ee t:.n1oss ho •is otherwise :i.oo-.JJ.y l:..eld. DcHvoT.ed this 1-..T rIW1./zA. 5 t1, 'Ju 1 ·"· ""1 ___ ;;: ~ ~ .,.,, 0 • :<· -:- ·. . . ·; 3. W. Ki..TITI JODGZ. . I ,, .' 'l -· '.,., . ... i: .. . '. .rA;-.····