Mbogora Burosika vs Bwire Musiba (P.C. Civil Appeal No. 53 of 1990) [1990] TZHC 348 (19 December 1990)

.... .. , / ----· .... J]f Tifil TIIGil COURT Of Ti.l!Z2TIL. · . AT Mlth.NZt... P.,C. C:tVIL J.PIBJ:J., NO. 53 OF 1990 (F.ron tho decision of tl:.o District Court of I.iurJor.m. in Civil L;j,)Ocl l!o. 121/89 - Qdcincl lhmsi rrinory Comt Civil Cn:3o lfoo 11Df'.39) lIDOGOR.L. BUROSDCf.i. a e • ('I • o • o· o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o e o o o o o o o,, o o o ,, o JJ):?:JlL.:.1.TT Versus J3ifJJ'Jll MUSII3li to•••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••ooooooooooo lIBSPOlTIEHT J'Ul)GMENT. M,WlS.lNYA 1 J. r Tho rosvoJ."1..clcnt J3wiro s/ o Msibn. successfully suod tl:o r.:y::iollriT\ r-r0ogorc. s/ o J3urosikc, o.t J3wooi Prina.ry Court in lw..noDc District in c, oJ.cin of a. pioc:o of land. Tho lcnc:1 in dispute ·wr:-,s doola,:roc1 to 'be· t::.c :x-:o::10:.--ty of tho rospontlcnt~ Tho r,pp., llent ondo his first c..pJ:)02-l to n.::.sonr. Diotrict Cow.•t c,nd 1ms oquclly 1.uwucoocsf'u.l and hence this second c.::)poc,1:. J3oth li ticc.nts olc:inocl ct tbo trinl tl:,.c.t tho lend. in diD:9uto wc.s ciOJ:1 lend which tl.:0;7 in~.:ori tad fron their fc.t:::.ors. Tl:.o rcs;1onc10;1t ocllod tuo -l1. tnossos to S1fJstc:nti2.to Lis cla.ir.1 r..nd tI:..oso uitnc Dsoo 101-0 Er. Hc,on@l s/o Toec (P.W.,2) nnc1 Esiim s/o /.'}yoo'bo (P.W.3). co.lloc;i two witnossoG 11[',j]0ly H:r·o Hjngi s/o !fucinc. (Dolr.2) ·c.nc1 r:r. IIC.f\U"'U s/ o I.f:)o.yo. (Do W. 3) to s1.:.J):;_)ot his co.so. Dot: tcnt:i.f:i.o e. t)-:-t 2.ri ic::;: cs tJ::.oy lmon tho lnnc1 in cJisi;-t1to 'belonged *o tl:.o o..11:1olln;1.1t. 1foll, I tl:.ink t~;.is co..so fell tc bo c1ochloa. on t: .J q_1.:ost:i.o:1 of crodi1Jili ty of wi tnossc·s. Tho trinl cou:rt 'bolio•v·oc.1 V:o rosi)C.cont 1 a ui t- nossos encl I cnn't so.;; t:·Loy ,roro w1.·onc. In t>.c no:"Jorr,ncri:.n of c,:,;)oci, c'.ll whet ,tho nrir>clJ.mt ocmtonc1s, is thd tl:o trinl 001.1.1.•t c:.ncl .Uif:it}.'ict Corn?t wore vr.rong to be licvo t1:o two ui tncoso o for t:o r9rnonc 1 .cnt inntorn7. of , 'oclioving his wi t:1csscs. :.t he has fciloc1 to :1)0L1t 01-1.t 1. s to w::.- -.:i_s v:::iraior to scy tb.ct tho two coti_j__•ts JOlo-w crrca. in tl':.c concJ.;.,,_sion t::.o · 1--onc::.0;. In tl--:o event t:1:i.s 2.1):.;,or,l fcils a.nd it io disniosoc1 ,;;:.t:-. f oostco Order a.ccordincsly. fil :MWJ;NZA. 19/12/90 Jud£,T.lcnt d.olivorod in cllro'.Jcrs in tho p.:osonco of tl~ i.)t.-;rlios • . ' ' ----~--- Jo L. EWL.I.USA!:T"f.L .~fil .. 19/12/90