Vedasto Claveri vs Cosdert (PC. Civil Appeal No. 200 of 1988) [1990] TZHC 595 (30 November 1990)

\tz l..I'rT.:J.,LLTE J"1JiU&')ICTICfi (?C) CIVIL iS'P::J,.".l, l:0,200 OF 1908 1986) Vt!Oi..STO CT · 'T'7.J: . · ·. · · . 1' ···t1 . "T !.J 0 ... :.\i ;'..,·;:. G ~ 11 o .; o :a ~ .. a·o..o· o·.·-o· O:, ,0 e •• ~ e. 0 1111 0 o ::,., · ... / ., f • c,.);, .JC" 4 .. ...L .£ -1 .r..J:·J -·' ®SDE:iT J . U :;; G 1 E 11 T -----·----- "'""Ul.,.,...,.:1 :. . J •· •• J.~ ·•..,lJ.• ..., .. ;.. ... , rcspon "..ont for i-oc0vory of ~~ I)i(;ClC '1:f a o··.o.;.:)a h0 e,lJ.01;0; ;>.c _ ln.t-'.;or hl".(1 nocupiocl by f-:1rcc. It we.s :.:is s·'"lry t:~t 011 1 10/2/7G .':.o haL 0 •• -::rt- t!:.o 01.lit 0 : ahr?.:;Jba, f'r:m one 11:croza 1-::w,-:,•,i :-:" )r r;b.s,80 1 009• T..:c -:rc:.:,-.·".:1r livo1 in. tho sL,?.::1)n, fer e. w:::.ilo nml went -,J r;.a.zy-a, ,t,.crc o::c clicc':. i:..1 ·t::.;0 ;.;;-c.24' __ :.1·985. Soon after le.er ·:c0,t) ·. t:o: rco:;');::. .. '.ont c.::,j,.,DG~: :f:c owncr:J.°:.ip of tl:o stu t woi:1211 J:>orosr.. ::!:r: ... 1,j.. a .... : Both pl'.I'tics pr::>·'.ncccl :::09;.::;:cn~ .. i7.:6 a.ppoll2J.1t pro:·;.:c,.>-:. -:i:10 o.· ;:,.corninc tl:e s;:,,).o w:::ilc t: .c :tospc.1 '.c •• ·t pr::c'.ucctl n. willJ 'E·.o -;;:-:i.~~1 c --irct rcjcc-tct\ both cbow.,0i.:t::J 1c1 f,un: :.l'Xl.O. ;1 ·the p::-..rtios :.;-> . ..:' •• ~~- r;l ·.i::-.: ·to ·i:;.> .. o o:·.,:··.1bc.1, 1 ' . disnisso·: ·i~~,c .:-,::1:··0llc111tl3 m.ti:i; ['.l"ll orc:!.crc1 a. st,tv.s qm -ill t;:o clan dcci·:.oo on t>.c 01-mors\ip o? ·i:."·.o. :i::.p.r.h ?1:1.c r'.ppcll.:-:.::: i.ti."lSi..:.ccoosfulq n.ppc<".lo,: to ·i.;;:;c Dio·;;ric·~ Cot::·t 1 :.1:i1-r to -t~:is c01..rrt 0 Tho trio.l cov.nt rcjoc·7:c~'. -:.:o rcz::,,n ·:cnt• s nill ":1ocr>..uso it wn.s riot wi tncssorl ::iy c'J1Y clana nor.:· ·::r o:Z -::o t-::s-Lto.:, ... I pcl"l1Got. -'Gl:o ovi:lcncc nnd fine: (WC,1 .. c::c rospo .. Y'.vn-i; 0 ":·.i t·:;o .. 1. -:; 1 -..t wr..s t:·c cr.-,ec. I n.aroo -,d. th the triDl coui-t ·t.J.,b.t t'.::.c will ur.s v0i,:, Wi"ch rcc;r,,rr: ·i:;o •:;:-:.c o:,,,lo doouno.11-t produccc1. b;y- t:o !"..p1--cll;,r.:l; I :i?.·,il Ji;o cc;-, ... n out -'c'.-- .. c roc.o:~;.10 ,f:,y :;,c trial cciurt reject cc'!. i "t.t Wen if i ·i; Wc.S :r,ul1Cl with ,irrcc,1,:l,~i ;ico t.1.nd tl:l':own out 1 still ·l;;1cro wn.o on:·.c11cc '.)f scvornl witnesses, iuclu::lin,::;- o1.-J1a oc;:ihcra -'c'"t t'·"' "pncll:.n•:, , .. ,,1 1 1,-,i 1 .-~1,t t 1 ·0 '"' 1 :<>....,ba fror m .. l::.cr"'Z:-t l':kwa.bi ~~ J ~ ...... ., _ • -V '--' .l ~ v · .c .,. .. •· - .. ,,, .,. ....L a..> ....... --'·· " •·-' J V ..... for s:-,s.80,ooo. I sec 110 rcaoon ,,fri;y· tho.t ovit.:cncc W1:'.,.'3 not c.cccptod. na~H,..,,. t''" J' 11 rl,.,..-iont of -{·'·c lc..,•·••v,d "!'.:.N•-..;,...t r·r ... ,,.i·s-'-""'".A-0 '·c Ti-,"' ·,f t··c . --.,.-t.J ,.., ;a.a - I.. t -..:.,...,. •,1,,u • ..,,., 't:.v U.,J.,.,,(, ~ --~ I 1..,,.. .. ~ view, CVC!:l 1· :f' J., . . , O"lc W"'"' vn11· ,., -it is .. .,,,,., n...,• .. ,..tT" c•,-'ro-- .... -.-,- 1.,- . . •. ·•t .., \I.. · ,., .. Jt.:1 c-.,, 1 .... , • '•-'-ill ..:....h....J.t.v (...,._ "' .. r.:.. v . ··•· ... t.,,/ .r, ,,. _., <." fc:Jr.lc cr.;:ilo"i. ,lisposo of cJ.r-.J.1 lr.nrl t0 M outsi:kr• Yu.;, I ·: .. ;r . .:-:.:, !:i\t is the 10.l.J but I.c'..ont't lc.nw 'lflc•if-:.cr t·.c suit o:2.1: 1 0 i:J c'.. cl-,21 ·:-::--~·CI1tyl .. •· I• . ,. " '

I l \

2

Theres'..'..' c cl::-,i1 ol-'.'.iainc the aha Ohonba. -c:.·.e qu.::;Dtion •Ji' r.:;lr·11 l<' .. ml was out of cr-L:::tion. Tho. is<i1,":.(l. ll..".S ·.t,.') c'!.oci ·le -y,,.,,- -::.c:a1. tl:.oso ·in-ro p~rti.e.e: to of 110{;::_ lawa:o c· ·c- 1 .Tto .:.:. ~ ,re:-. ::c:c ju~s-:c,;1t f0r tl:c a,)_1,GllMtq the sui-t s!:n.nbo. bQ), :J::..-:z ·b : i ... , ;f!::.o l'c;:r ,,n- ~0nt.. to ;:ey costs. :,; JUDQE. ii, f !' 411 ... - •'