Charles Matoke and Another vs Peter Samwel (PC Civil Appeal No. 95 of 1990) [1990] TZHC 320 (20 November 1990)

) ·r.·,. <fe_. ~~s-~ HT 'E:'.E :·IrGR C( ·c:;u. 1 0.2 T.,:.:.:;Z.•\Kit ... rT I 1 rn1:..?iL /..P?ELLLTE JTJRFDICTION (PC) CI7IL APPEtJ, 1;0.95 OF 1990 ( '<'om J-'·o i!or-i"'1·ol'\ o·" ., c· "1· s"·t1·c-'· C,---:,-,,1. ·o·" 3,-,r·r,·~-- J.1· · .. •. V1·.·······t: 1·r 1 ~.J.. ... t, .... ..,1_.:;> .L ... l. U ..• ., .:.J ~ V , .. '..J.V ..L '-' ...,.4.r .,\J .,I., J.'.l.-·.:, 1 ---~ - C . · 1 ' 1 ,·· 61· · 0 1 ° 0 9 .B ✓-. C . " Cd .,.., --~ . . 1 J.Vl •~j)l)O;:-, .. ,.,, 0.L ;;U - OJ.Ore •Lev• oni:;o,,;Jr,; .!..:'l.i"lClp.::l, Di ..... •-r;cJ. ·1·T...,,,.s.,,.•.r,,,+c "1l'CJ Or1·. 0 1·-':1,.,l ····.•.~,,- 1 ·- {ir·•·-=ii'- Pr1.'""'=y f",o-•-,,-'· l;·,·;,•1·1 ..... 1.:>l- .i.. ~v .u.. ...... 0 .1.. ..... v c...,u __,.. ... L O J. ..., l.J. .JL....... . .... ... -' ..1 • ...1. v ........ , Caso 1o. 135 o:f 1989) 1 • C:::!.D.L:;JS :.!1'..1 1 0KE 2 • SFERLCC:;: IITI-13ELETE ) ~ !)T'DT r , ,,.,1s ) ··········"···"••0••·••0•··4,;49C11Jl.J.J:'i!JJ.J.LJ..'.'-.L .. ) VErtS'OS · PETIB SlJl1'TELc •• ................. •. o • ... " ••••••• ·., ~ ........ o,. ·• ,RJ..:--SPOi·f.DbET J u D G II E N T ------ --- -· -- .• --- WJT::."Eill t. • J s .,___ 'I'llc ·[;wo s.ppelb.nto wcru ·i;.' .•; ::i::1.-;oc·i.;ors in t::o ·:::~L•.l.. 'P.:o rJGpo::·"..c:1·:; ]: .. ·: 1-rc.11 0 '. 1 ti ,.c·w ~ ""vl -::: o:Ji t ::{/:,::.is·;: 0 .. 10 Jo~ Obiyo. - i:c ·:: .i'. O!-;.~ ~ 1r ... ,:i..:. .~1-:,-; a:~tl ciZi...:r° ~ .. :·r,1..j:;or ,,£ 02 .. t·:10, so::.c -ro;!1 -'·'. ·1 .. .,.., ~ .... ,, .. ·'· l• . . 0 ,1,.1.,.:.:,, .•.,:'.111 ·'· ., --, 1 ('"1 J\ -- JJ '.1::lG ,.-,,., ~ ..... ..::. .. ot10ro frcz·1 ·i;·.c ::'J.rot o..ppoJ.l'.'.i1t 1

s :· .. :r.1c. Oft. c:Jc s i:.o-:. .. :')' ·'·.' . j': 1 .'_.:··,0;:·;; '-lc/1·01."''s .1:.1c t. .. : socui'.i.~~ appoll2.;.i."b c1.('..i:UL0·:l "'Gi:02· -::-rc.:ic ) .is ,.-, .o:.•<;-'", e :op- t: · . ..::i:~ :.::co. T.:.c firGt c.1,r>;ci.l.'J:t r:,loo cl ... iai.G. 0-;::::4,.::-s:-.i:~ o~.' -~;.:.. 1 ~cc s0izcrl 1':,::,:1 >.is J:1.omc. '1';1:i -rL-,1 oo-. ·_:.·t ;_•):1.r:1.. ;:_. - i:-r ~ _L ; '

• • .i,,, .. :::CG '.'nd f01:.11L'. 2.11 C?.t···1c seized '.:>clo:.,,c;,x: ·co ·:;:·.:: j·,:,.r-:;Loxt ('.IS: .·:;,')x J:.' .:1 o:)i, ·,--: .1.:.1c1. tlis~.1iG8CC~ t: .o o:1j0ctions of boiib. r,li:)ollc..ts, -t:·:.e:,r Luw-;.·_.:.;c,Jw..:;::·.:ll;,· 2.,ppo;.l0:..: 'Go t'.:.e DirY::..·io·G Court? now ·f ·.oy :.·.:.:re co:.1G to thi8 CJ.:j;'[;. . , ·i~ · .G 8;"'..t,ti. .. ·:;::·:a -1;:-..e juclgr.'lc..."lt c:o!:ito:r Jo::n o:.,iyo w--.o wo.,s f otin.rl by t.'.:o lrmor cc.c·ts liC.::,lo to :rcf1.::n(l ·:;."\c bri::10,;•real tb. in f·,,11 -1·pc:·,l0cl r;.;:;c,inst ->o (.w~~:' ior. oi:. -::.u :District C'.">1..1..rt w]::.icb. upheld t'·.,1t :;:: -.':o trb1 cou2t,. I, will start ui t1 t:.c appC'·,1 o.::· 'l;;::.,J first c1,p1)'Jll.-:i.:.t. ::c oppo::;Jcl six (6) cows s0izoc. from ;:1.is >.one s,,;;;r:i.ne:; t;1oy were >.io, 1 r}ley ,.,ere ci::oc!. b0causo i·:; Wc'.1,S s.Jid tl,e jnd.gr.wnt r.lc.-to:r hid them t'.core.., T:10ro we,s evic:once -;;;•.o..t t1:e juc_,-::ient cl.,Jl,i.;:;r 1 r; :30i1 Bcns0n John bro,::.·:;::t Ji;::..cir own cattle to r0)lace t:iose saic'. :\c · .:::, -;;::.e irst e.ppcll ·nt 1 s pro)crty, t1:;.io s0.:LJ-tlo<:. -:/.! :~~-;-;tor a ::.-0r as -'v:·.j_::J c..t---·;oJ.l:1:1·~ WP .. S ccncor:1or..~ .. 1s for t>.o soorJnd. :~~Jpoll2-:.1t the c rittlo w:;:co ::; :;izod. )ro the l:or..10 .J:.C' t::c j:":,:;:1ont l ·b·'· - •... ' 1 'c, ·'·},,..,+ ·. (,.," ' · ··· 11-···'·) ,.,, l 'r _J, .•.· .. , -•-·. ···-. •• , ... - ·'· C.0 ... or, ... ).SC G,,l.J .• , •• - ...... ,C r..,1, Cl.:,,)1JO ,·.r.11 .-· .• ,(. 1-..01:1, ''··V•• v .. .:,, ":,.: •• o\J supyortod. by ovic.enco m1 record. ::'ia::,,lly t>.o o,ppual c::.' ·:;"·.o ·;;;L:-·l !:!.pi3ll ,at J oJ:n O:-ii;yo • ::.:o - c orn;,l:-1inu tl:o lm-rc:: c otu•·l;s orrol i;1 :',H. ::i: · .. s ·:;: _0 :;:·ospo:1,ont full rd'i..111cl af :is "!Jridevror:.H½. wi.·;;·.m:t tc1;.d,.:.c into accc.J:: .'.·:.: ·. ·.:'. 1i1re(. --h '-1·s ,'·•r•:··!· r ,"' f'f- ( 1 5) · -, db- · 1 ·"· • -•¥•-, (7) '·1-· "• W1 l, ·- . 01..,Lc:,--' .,G ,Lor 1 t,OCn . J; 02..1. s 8.Xl ,)rl,; ,:.,. iJC .. ,, C.11 ~cr0.c,. ............ /2.

2 But t>.0ro wo..s Clridence it was he .w~:o -ook his l'.D.1.lg.-i.ter 2.n';,;' :f:r;)r:l t:1e mo:trimonicl :iomo and they wont to Ke .. 1ya, tho rcspom:'..ent ;,2, t0 sook ,:,, tlivorc0 i1: •.::or o,bsc.:nce, -clJey were to 1L:;,1c. I dismiss t:c ·:;!:rGo o,ppo'.".ls with cos-1ic;. . ·- '"✓ '. . 1 · ~ ~AT MWllfZA I /', ✓- F. /::·(/ 2_0/ 1 i /9q. ' ;; - ~ '-, ,: •" \· '· 'f1' l ' . . ''/ .. ' . ' ' ' ;.t,,._ f ' ;~~' JUDGE. ,, l ·, .. ,, '· j ✓;/ ' . -. ... l': .J, ·,>.- ,. I . ·:,.'..-'' -- \ , . . Q,· ,.