Bakari Hassani vs Republic (HC Criminal Appeal No 107 of 1990) [1990] TZHC 208 (19 October 1990)

j '· ?JT TIO IIIOI: CO"J:.lT o·~ 1 .r/.1:TZ.'.lTI..'. ... :;:::tL:..TJS J".ti.7.[.:0 ICT!OlT (Utt•iC..l., =-o.'_:;irJtl-y rtr.Gli dOUil'l' C:lJET.Itli .'!'.:?:UL l.O,. 107 OF 19,90 ~~i3irw.1 Oril-nn.."'1 Oc.oo Ho. 4 of 1550 of tl10 niat."ict Cou:ct. o~ Li:~ Diat~--:1.ct r-,t "L:i.ncli . · ·nofa.roa .A.u. Scllm:i :1~., I>i 1t1 ... i'ct l:ir,.:;ir:trtoto :0/JC.'.llI Rt...3S.filTI- .- , ... • • ... • • • o .. ., . Vo:csus ·. :t:J;"{i.'OMD11lt:rr ·, ' ,. ·,: ,? ~~, .. J, . ., ' I ' '• : ;;-/'f;.•,. ,• • • • : 'l'hc e.wollt wr oon.viet9c.t of ii)iZ:'Gl-t~ r.1:::1 oto-&'J.i.."iG•,. Ho •.W'E'.s • ,. . .' • ., -&,· ,. aontohcod to fivo .Yl?t..l"fl ir.lp:t':i:so11nm1t ;;u.1. tho _fj.o '~ count r.rid >bwolvo montl~ • ' ·, • ; :, .,.1, J, •• ,. •. • w •• • • • ' sonr.10.m.; ilt tl scoom.·· •ool.U'lt, 1i9 · oo soi;roq.,, cc nc.:u:Jj. 1 011,tly. 1Io was · . . • • . r ... iatttiatiod t'n4 ;,.o. nou r-,ppoc1o. · . .-1:. · ·. '". ' . .. .. 'l'hr~ wc.s •<Xl:'od.ibi~ ovidonco ·t!:w,t o. bouoc bcU11uik;; to ~n: :ttaho.:t'Uld. ~ • ' . .... . .•.•. ! l'J)csl10bokolo -r 't,rok01\ into c,t tI11ili11i.:Li cn .in 1t~.chL."'\Slroc township on , f . • • • tlio niaht of 31 Dooopbor 1989. : aoV'O.i. .. cl. hiono 1roj;'C ctolon f'l.'om· -tlb.o uso. Mdonoo. wrs t1J.ao giv011. thr..t 11.\7 t1. fo,i · hou:• ~ ;tr.tor, on tbo · ,,- . ·' { "90rni11g of' 1 Jc.J.llt.::i.7 1990 tho . C,j_)},)clJ.r.:n i-.nd t!1.o· soco "lU. c,ccuood wbi:>. 'Wl\S, c?-so • onviotod. of tho of'tanoos, r.nd ,t:.0 b:·.o 110t t:'.:pporlocl 1 1:0ni; 'to :::W4. Ibrdh?-o I . . -- I Issa. Li1-cn0r:1bo f'l1<l offorod. hio oi= ltlo1UJ which wc..jn bo'2gl.1.t for. .• / ohs. 1 1 Goo/• in t:o :pi"Oeonco of Ftt5 !40h-:-.ood To_a....,_. Th:i.-n 'in . then eot tho I .. .,,.. · cushions to ffl3 la'lr.,il SniM Cl1!,110im -to :,.sr;fo koopil-ig. Tho eunhions 110:ro l'OOO"Vorod et Isoril Chino,m•o !wt;oo on ~ Jc..""DJ.Cry 1990 ir a, ooc.roh condu.ctod I b tho polico. 1to c.ppoll.r.nt he :-,bccoMod after tl·.c ;.'.c 'ring dcto wm /' ft,a,d 1,:,- 11><> oowt 'll11'ln ho ,.,.,, ba1''G °':'carted to thu c'cu>l prison., So ho wn.s not pro:JOnt duril\z t?10 'iri..."1 of the cr.oc. . Tho tA ,J. o.".'.gistrnto nceoptod tho •osocution 0"111.donoo t'nt! ilwolcccl tho doctz-:i.J.1.1) of rocont possosa1 ~~ cppollc.n.t ur..a coi,victocl. a.a oh8.liZod.• Tho 0vid.oi100 by tho wo ,n. t1caooo, l'v14 Ibr.:-:·J.n c:;:ul 111'5 lfohr.mod tht tho ppollt>.nt c:.n.'. t10 sooond t.oQttocd he.cl t~:o ob: cu::-.;. .1.Gno on tho oomtng ot S. J~,y 1990 rcnc:i.l1oi1. iu1chrllc1'3od w.c.1. t:1c:.~o ?cs no rccson to d1sboliovo tt.c:t ovidoneo. Tho ::-,i)J.)oll;:ri.t hod r..boco11dod ·:'.lOtoro tl1.o . I

I

2

hoti'ing d.r:t.c lf..tl.ch 11r.rJ fi'lcoc\ ,in·_ '..!,in °,: . .-oooncc. • T:.10 t,:>ir,'.l mt;gistrr.to ·· ·. r ......... • p.rocoodod to >,on:::- tf,G cc.so in t:·,o . ::,i:.:cdco.·o:t tllo [',)'(>OlJ.::-..nt under soo'jlen 22d(1) ot tho Ct:-:Lliml ?rool~:-o_ Lt 1fG$- .. J!10 n~))ll;nt 'tfr>,a pl"osont in tho cow:t: 011·'·10 Jo.nur..li 1950 ·;/:on t::3 ,:102,;;JinG -'trr.s cdjoi,rnod. to 3G Jct.V:~ !'990.· T).1011· :10. r,bocplllt:;t. -•otl lrwtJ:"ul oustodf 1:>efo:ro tho cl.a.to ' '., • . ,. J .,..,. ~ 1 • ,· I, 'IC:.,, ,~ • t,. , , • , tixo~ fol"' tho· !oc..:i:-i::ic. o±:· t:i.o -m-;sc... ,'g-:.0. ,t;-icl ·1':lcir-.rt;.:-r:l;o o.ctod within • t . . ~ ' .. f llis pow6rn :iu1 ~JocoodincLvith l;-0 t::ir. iii. t!,lo. ,,b!J?l'lCO of tho appoU.t,- 'l'ho o.ppcl:L.i11t· crJu10t 11011 m:-,y; ho wcs d.oilioc1. en 01;>110l:tv.nity to p:coaont his clof onco .'booc.u.'3c ·:lo llc.d ld.1Jscl,f (bscoQ~,. :fll'ltl f3actJon 226( l) of tho Ctininr-l IT.ocod.tt,:o Aot givoa l)OUos ··io tho tri21 ··couJ.'t to conduct tho tt-ir..1 ill ho ;;,.,lJ30nco 9f tho rcCt.1.00(!. J?O:.·son, , iri. eiucli. dit>euustc11CQs, 1' t1dcnont of tho ti"irl .60{:·t iri'·-not r..s clotc.ilc_d ca, it d bo, but tht c1oon i1ot 1:inko tho p:.:ooooc1.i:1as r. nullity. Tl:ol'o n:r:o a. fo,r •- . orrora f.r1. t1.0 jttd{rilont, but 011 t::.o (;\iidonoo on l'OCO:i:d, th0ro ,,r:.s -e~ot.ont ,, · .. j ., .• ' t I \ . .. . . (M~cfv-. :.ru.ctr;o · . 19, Octob;;;-, 19S'O . '· t ~ ... p,-4,. i'.-. ' -· 1- .•. : ' .. . . . , f •. I , . ··• "'1 .... ~ !' . ... ; / . I.. . ,: . ,. - •. ~ .-i' .. :• fA\ ...... ~ •, \ • 1' i ...;.,. ' " i -· ,..u .... ,.,;; ... I '•