John Ibatila vs The Republic (High Court Criminal Appeal No. 73 of 1989) [1990] TZHC 53 (29 September 1990)

... :m . -,., .,:·,pp:_· .. 1 :-o. 73 OF 109 OlIGiliIL C ..... 1 ___ ,:111·:1 ·c;,--.:,, ··-r, {-.1"' 0'" 19-o9 ·o·'I-,

• ..,.)-..,.' J ·'·• '... 0 V ) '.J.' ·.1:.L.i..!...J . ...., ,, """' .·: "'--·" :.:. e JOITIJ 1.n1·.;::n ... · ••• o , •• , ••••••••••••••• , • APFcL1111r.T . ( O~';:G, ACCUL:GiJ) VOl'SLlS 'I'llL; :·_:?L-:.JLIC ...... -.-,c.mo·r .Tm ) i 1.1 11 " o o , 9 o o .!> o o o ~ :i .,. " o 1., o "' tJ e O !:Li...1JJ.C"' ~ .Dill11 l J_UDGHEi! -;-1 /• .!." o:...:., •. 1i.o -c.Jc·- f'o,-.··,-,i· ·r V h.J• • .i.C..,.-.1 C!:i.il1011ji-:::t s. ,. .. "l 0 .... ,1...- 0 C2.:i lJ.onji, 12/6/Cr; 11 ( o:;:w. · EO~cuTm)

• ~ ..... ,..., ... _ -.;; .• ,.,:. -l ........ l]<IA. """'4•••·· ' I !,.c, c,:n be :_;lcc:,.cc .1. ::r Oi".i t.'.c rccorl'.. o1· -:rccooc.1.in ·;;:; of -11c l r.rcr court it io oVi(.c;ri; --.J.'.'·c ·,,·>.@. ·lLc c.l):cllc:.r .,_,:,i,02.rc1. Lefore tt.o t1,icl . ,... ...... J-rnt '-.-• +'..,"" .• ........ ., .... O ,.,'"',..., 0 VCT- +-. ·,:1.· ·-, .... 1, he. lJq,J..::,·l, , •. c,a.u .. ,. v ... c C-.·.-'-· ..• u, ...... - ..I,''·: .. , .• ,, •.••.• prcrnr.mbl,Y o.ok.cr.:.. 1rhotb.c:r he "..:·:,i·tc·. c-:.: ,.:.o:;.1i-:'.. t'ic trut:: ·c.,crcof: I>rosccutor na.r~.ttc~: t10 :i?--.,o·s ':.f t].:..u cc:.oc o ff .Jj:c:·.1011ti0110::, cine:., iJrcstu:1nbly_, ../ the c.pi)ollunt wn .. s :-,G::o.:. :ric·:;.11e:r ::c C'.:.°'..;·.1i•·;;o1. J:!.' :'..Gnic<:'.. t).::.c f.:-.cJ.;c tho:rcof' • LikoWiGc the c.,ppcll:-:a· rJ:-:-.iC. 11 I ['...'•.1i• tL<.: f:- .. cto u.8 truo":. ITavi11r; l'O(;L!J.<:. to Thero w2.o in tl.i.o in:Tcc:rc c-:,.::.:o m1 ci.s:"'.i.1:.:ision by· -lie n,n,ollc'l1t of -::.c :fM·i;s which in i.W co11sic1.crcc:. vicr co;·.1prcb.cr cc.'. r-, f\1.ll r:.c-:,unt of tho oL:c11co.- IIr::viu,:; so .foun:1.. QXJ., Jccl.1. I ,::cco1'c:.in:) .. _· Uj_1l20l. .. '. t].1c c0i1Vic·ion of' -:;;.10 lo11cr court. court. I now turn _-;;o -he r2,.1cotion of -t\c :::ionto11co inr.:-ce:.:. ty ·chc ·triGJ.. Tho tric'..1 ::ic-::·;io'vl'.:-,:o 1·r.'.1ilc scn·c::;_1ci:n.:;· t21c Cl.l)i":ollr.nt i.1<'., .. 1.c t:10 fol1011inc ro;:-in.rk. . / c..':.otcx:rcnt sentence is oC'..llo:l for. The c:,ccurJc.1.. Hill tl:oI'cforc ::~~~ i'. fine hin for t1c c::crciso oi no:i:oy,:Zro:.1 t1c c--:.1.::.:t. o1:ivic-us, in of -cJ.:c offcn1.or ,.'.11."'.. oc;rhii -i:in ic t'lc fi: •·i; ::itor ·!;011,-.:s rofor:·.1c"';ci :1, uJ.1cl ~ co11foooio11 cj:i ::" c:i-:1.·.:0 7 :i..a r.11r:c:Jc ... -N ·-: °:Jc:,:i:·ii1~·: it out, is t"l.

In Cox r...1 g l-T.;:; i 'll' t, .A:,:. J t Mrs. Si] .' .. c. :for t>.c iv:_T'.)lio OHDER: 1 .. , ..'..:. 3 scnte;:.cc :'.: c;." ilJ.Li. :o :Zi vc t~1ous::-.n( 1 :. or 29-0'.;-90 . ,;:<•, .. 1 . ,I ,,,.,. /' , .. ~J ,:-v,,.,.,J':'-. ( ·.'. J :.: : :· .. ·.'.;.:.) . .--·- .,.,.,,, ~-..::, ''::J.2.qQ.r_