Omary Selemani vs Maulidi Nzomukunda (PC Civil Appeal No. 217 of 1990) [1990] TZHC 290 (12 September 1990)

~ ,.. -A I (,QVvr-+ jj SM IH '7'l·:E man C01:1T OF TANZ.-.:.-;·u. '¼ . ;.'..T i31:Iit·J 1JLO l..PP:'.:uL.:'};; J1./llI3DICTI ON (Pc). :ci:ir1 :P.2, =.0.211 or .1990 (0::1 tho· decision of ·1/10 Dis-:;rict Court of )}E12,1•::.n1..1.lo .Jis:trict c..t !Ji2.ar2.mi.lo. in Civil LJpoal xfo.1 of 1990 - Bcfo:i:'o K. T. J • Rus-.::9c, sq., J.osid.c.m-'G r,!a-:;is:;;rato c:.i:c.l C:.:'li,:i.n Prica.ry Cour-'.;. 0ric.:.12.l Civil ·J0.se - ·o.13//J9) OLJY- S.EL'E!r-l.tJ·lI , .... q ~ • o ., ,, ., o .... , • o ••• o • • 4> o o o a •• ., .,, o $' o • , a 9 •• o • a o "' "'.l.J·PL.tJ:::!: VERSUS 'I\I '·DLIDI . VZ''· 1 ;1-r:"TI·Fi) r n=- pc· :r, = .. :, J.', !,,,. . J.• V1- lJ_L.-,. J.v, • o - • • c, o o-, i, o.,, o o o o ,, o o c-, no• o o o ,, ~ o • • o ~ ••• •- ...;.f.:J IJ .. ,·)J:., •- ,; .'I ·. . .. JUD GM EN ~~- ' J • UtJN'YEPLl•' /1 ·{ lr The .a,ppelli?..nt vas ·t:10 o1aintiff in t::e :1iri.?,l. ITe sued t:10 . . - . . , . resporic.-int for w).:-.c.t <1ppeo.rs to 1.:J0 specific po:·::fo:c::tc:',:,;;e. I-b -wo.s mid.ispuJi;cd t:,.o;i l:.acl e.,gTcccl t:io ruspondcnt was ·:;o s,).1 i.'..nd t:e appellPn· " . . . . .. to bey, a grinding iill, Il'..1.Ston 26 l":qp., at t.':,o price of s: ... s.,.50,000,. On 25/5/85 'JG;'..0 P'-·''.8.SC.r (;,ppoll.-.1·i;) made a· clown p~':.1Cl1t f ;:.s20,ooo a• • '• • • • ": • • 2 .. ad. la·or he gave ov: br:i.clcs w;:;.ic ... war va.luic::.l a:~ s'.:cs-. 10,000. ·:Cl:0 0-PPOlL.11.t. 2..6 yo·t 'i:. pew 5l:s. ( 50 jooo-30·,060) 20 ooo· :a.riy· 'how tlC rcspo::.c:1.;;: .. Lt • • , I ., . . . , '. • • c1llowcd J.;lle appe.llant/piu:c .. ::i.scr to .use -t;e D<;l,cl"-.i.:c •. O+t 1/10/89 -c.".c rcspondcni)vonOl' wrtc ·. t·; t::c n--'i;l:.cr gL,Y giving :i.i.:. a two f.lO~"lth no·:;ico . . wi·::J.in w.'.ic:.1 to rosovo -:;.· o :~ac'.:ine froo l:is p1•0i:1is0n as o 1·ra.1t0t to 1:-,·: dif'y i·i; for ot!.:or purposes. T}i.e appollnnt P!oicstccl, arguing l:-.0 :.ad 'bcT,.:,: .t t110 :10.,c:'.inc ui J.;h •;;::,o plo•;; 2-:_cl s-truc.;v.ros up9_n .-r::io;i i ·;; rested, >.o ''r2..a invo!:inc l0g2l n2.:r-..in. -:;: .2:ii. .nnc1. inclui9s all ;:·.Ed; J"rouL1g or sti:,j,1c",.L,:; 'J:.: it. .'£-tor t:oir religions bara.6a (Bakwata) f dlcC: to ::.;ottle -Le ,"..isp::::;o t:ic appellant Si).cd. Thl tr,ic;1.l pri:-.mrJ' court .:.0lc.".. rn1a1imoi..lS vim·i ·.- .:.,;,; ::.0 1 101.,rr·:,t t',o fJ<-C 1 'ine to·:o·'•: 1 er lTiJ-1, t'. C s·"·ruc.,· 1 '"'0 ··,•, 1 c: -:·'"0 plo·'- .. • -( ,.,.. - --# - '-' v. -, t.,__ -- I., l,i.:...1., c.-- .... u.. -· . t., it o-;(•'l- ..,_c' the rcsponclont 50·~ c:issn;(;isfii:,c'. Mrl appc2..locl i;o ·:;:·.o Dis·riet Co.:::•-'.; Tlw appc.=-..l wont before -:-.o J.esic10nt ;:Ic·,,;: 5 istra·:;e (Hr. Ruscoa) sit·t;Lc ·o t::e Dis·t::·iCJG :::.:aeis·rn;::e,. '.:Ji!:iaran1lo Tho lcc:.rrJ.crl. 2..;::ip01lc:ite Lln{is·i;:..•eto rcvorsod t:10 clocisioll 02 t>.c tri:11 court on gro,"1.1,:. -'.;:·2,t -t;: .. e grin(:inG' .. ' . .. · nill. is a cb.attol w. .ic:::. is nov?::)J.e, H canno·;; "1c Sf'.id -o 110 inse'l.I',:'..110 , .n..,.or-1 .,.·,e c,•'-r,,c·'·u···o i· ••• ...,.•·ooc 1 0·1 In ·i;urn -t;',c ,,,,,..,r,ll· 0 ·1J. 1:irov~::""•. •:·· "s J . ..i.,. J... ,,. • O t; V- I.J ~ t, .,;, ., . L _.., O • · . .1 .. 1. ~ .... .,, ._, r ,,1 V , .... ..:;. - V ., •. ...,. appeal, ais 2.r(sl)!.kllt is ·;; .0 ,8 '..:.:.10 ·l;.-:;t wL.icb.evcr is c..·i;tc,,.cl:ed to ·i;l:.e lru:.:· . .. boc one::; part of it• .It is· agreoc: ·;;::·.e se.lc .. agrconcnt was specifically for ·Lo [;'I'inclinc- ,. L12 .. c:1ino Md notl'1iI1g clsu. I >:,.-c . The· appellant is . relyL1c .-:.1.0 doctrine .. ' .. . ,__ . . ... . quoted above t!:a w!1ic~evo;r is attached .. to. the la.rid ~ccomcs part of·.i·i;• . ,.... ·- . ... ... , ·• ~ ... . _.: .. . J· ,, f. .,. •"t ,-- . ~ -r ·t 1 ·J ....... .. - .... /2. / .1

• ' ~ ' \ \ \

2' -. I unlc he is arguing Ji;e opposite, he shoui.cl have 2.cquircd ;, L·,_:_c~ first a..1.tl ·tLcn clci,.1 nll ·c~:.c1,t is ate . .nding on i·i;. But b.c spccificc"ll3· bo::'.s-!1.t· n. 0)2a->.;tcl t:':.·.E:i; 02.J.1 >o fh:od on or rooovoc"',. fron the strv_c-v..ro concc:r.1cd, tho doctrine '.:.c relied on is iriapplic2}-;lo in t1is pa.rtic1.-.1o.r case. I disniss -:c c1,ppccJ. witl: costs. --- ...... ·--.::.i Dr.L!'.J:TJJCLO ~ . : . ,. . '\ V .. . . . - .. , . . .. •· J /:;,· ·, . ......._ .,/ .: '--. _____ __,,, - . r· ~ ~ ,./'' . ... :....., l. .. •· .. ~~¢" . ' ~ i ·, a:·_.,... ·t , r,. .,,... fl I )tt . / ' ; ';: .. 1+ t . .,trl. EB... JlJDGE.